November 16, 2026
On Failure and Making
The craft theorist David Pye once observed that all design is, to some degree, a failure. Every design involves compromise. Requirements conflict, materials have limitations, and time and money are finite. We can never satisfy every ambition we bring to a piece of work.
I was reminded of Pye recently while listening to philosopher and AI researcher Amanda Askell discuss the idea of an optimal rate of failure with Lex Fridman. If we never fail, perhaps we aren't attempting enough. Progress requires some willingness to get things wrong.
As a craftsman, I find these ideas closely related. Pye describes the compromises inherent in making things, while Askell considers the risks we must accept if we hope to improve.
In my own work, there is always a tension between what I can imagine and what I can reasonably accomplish. There is nearly always something I might have done differently. Yet working within these constraints is part of what makes craft meaningful. Making is not simply the execution of an ideal, but a negotiation with reality.
Perhaps the greater failure would be to avoid attempting something ambitious, or to become so preoccupied with an unattainable ideal that nothing ever gets finished.
Standards matter, and compromise is no excuse for poor workmanship. But success doesn't require perfection. There is a particular satisfaction in standing back from a finished piece, knowing its limitations, and nevertheless being proud of what you've made.